Freedom of donation and legislation: Arguments and anthropological assumptions

Main Article Content

José Enrique Gómez Álvarez

Abstract

The article shows that the best way for transplant donation is with an explicit consent. The article analyzes some arguments about transplant donation process and with some anthropological concepts specially the human act process. It begins with an introduction where it is exposed the Senatorial proposal for tacit organ donations in Mexico. In the next sections it is analyzed some assumptions and arguments of different donation systems. It is close with the conclusion.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Gómez Álvarez, J. E. (2019). Freedom of donation and legislation: Arguments and anthropological assumptions. Medicina Y Ética, 30(1), 197–211. Retrieved from https://revistas.anahuac.mx/index.php/bioetica/article/view/435
Section
Articles

References

1 Iniciative that reforms articles 313, 322, 324 and 329 bis, of the General Health
Law in charge of the Representative Alfredo Bejos Nicolás, from the PRI Parlamentary
Group (2018). Recovered from: http://sil.gobernacion.gob.mx/Archivos/
Documentos/2018/02/asun_3661463_20180206_1518024702.pdf
2 MERINO, M., UTURBIA, M. (2015). Bioethic problems on the organ donation in the
new Chilean Law. Social Science Magazine.66.
3 GÓMEZ, J.E. (2003). The Transplants. Mexico; Anáhuac University.
4 POLITICAL CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED MEXICAN STATES (2018). Recovered from:
www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/pdf/1_270818.pdf
5 VERNEAUX, R. Phylosophy of Man. Barcelona: Herder.
6 SIMON, R. (1987). Moral. Barcelona; Herder.
7 ZÚÑIGA, A. (2017). Transparency and Transplants: Is it possible? Bioethical
Dilemmas on the organ allocation. Bioethical Minute; 23 (2
8 GUILLERMO CANTÚ-QUINTANILLA, G., MADRIGAL, J., PALENCIA, J., BARRAGÁN, A.
(2017). How to respect the will to donate? Demand self-respect. Vol. 6, Num. 3
September-December
9 SÁNCHEZ, U. (1993). Ancient and new principles in moral theology. Mexico; Pontificial
University of Mexico.
10 PÉREZ, R., LISKER, R., TAPIA, R. (2007). The building of Bioethics. Mexico; F.C.E.
11 SSA (2018). General Health Law. Mexico. Recovered from: ww.diputados.gob.mx/
LeyesBiblio/pdf/142_120718.pdf
12 Ph. D. YOLANDA M. GUERRA GARCÍA, PH. D. ÁLVARO MÁRQUEZ CÁRDENAS. Bioethics,
Organ transplant and Criminal Law in Colombia. REVISTA PRINCIPIA
IURIS Nº.15, 2011-1
13 ZILLI, S ET. AL., (2015). Registration and format analysis for the organ, tissues
and cells donation consent for transplants in Veracruz City. Mexican Transplant
Magazine. Vol. 4, Num. 2 May- August.
14 MADRIGAL ET. AL., (2014). Score system for the allocation of kidneys from deceased
donors to patients in the waiting lists for transplants. Vol. 3, Num. 2 May-August
2014
15 AQUINO, T. (2017). Theology compendium, Recovered from: http://hjg.com.ar/sumat/
c/c58.html#a1
16 MORA-ARIAS M.T. ET. AL,. (2009). Opinion survey about organ donation. Internal
Medicine of Mexico. Volume 26, num. 4. Recovered from: http://cmim.org/boletin/
pdf2010/MedIntContenido04_04.pdf